top of page
Search

Repent, the end is near

It's weird that it's still April, but it feels like the end of the school year is very near. Actually, this will be the latest I've ever gotten out of school. This is the first year I will be in class on my birthday (June 29), and I'm getting close to being in the 50th grade. 50th grade? Yeah, I've gone to school every year since I was five years old. I'm turning 54 this summer. Do the math.



Or don't. I won't judge. If I've had success as a teacher it's been largely because I work hard to make sure students don't feel judged by me for their struggles in math class. Everyone has their strengths and weaknesses. I remind students of this often. And the reality is that students don't need the majority of the math we ram down their throats. If you're reading this your probably an adult. How much of the math that you learned in high school do you use? Most of the math you probably use is arithmetic. Not much beyond adding, subtracting, multiplying, and dividing. Have you factored a quadratic equation recently? Calvin? Yeah. He's a math teacher. JP? Well, yeah. He's a gifted math student and the sort that might one day be a math teacher.

It drives me bananas that we make students take so much math. I've got plenty of thoughts on the issue. Why? How did this happen? Why do we make students take so much advanced mathematics?



Why? I trace it all back to Sputnik. It was the event that scared Americans so badly that we as a nation reacted by attempting to create as many engineers and scientists as humanly possible. Not much has changed. If anything paranoia and xenophobia has only gotten worse on both sides of the aisle in congress.


How? Politicians. Nobody gets elected by saying they want more interior designers, graphic artists, and coreographers. That doesn't sell at the ballot box. Further, it always has to be a higher standard. I think it's too high right now.


I'll never argue math isn't important, but specifically WHAT is important needs to be up for debate, and the people that make these determinations shouldn't be math teachers and politicians. Currently the common core standards dominate the math landscape, but are they a reasonable? I think so if you want to be an engineer and are heading in a path towards studying the calculus. That's not most people, and the system doesn't work for most people. Teaching Algebra 2 in the states is akin to selling manure to dolphins. Dolphins? Yeah, the most random animal I could think at the moment. They don't need it and don't want it.


If not advanced algebra, then what as another option. Probability and statistics. That's what I would rather teach to most students. Students can see it everyday in their lives. For now the system is geared towards funneling all our student towards calculus. Don't get me wrong. I like calculus. It's cool. But I'm a math teacher. I don't have a hard time seeing that it's not for everyone. Further, I'm glad there are people that enjoy advanced mathematics. Thank you Alan Turing for breaking the Nazi codes during WW2. Thank you John Nash for sharing your ideas about game theory. Thank you to all the engineers that helped to put this cell phone my hands.


Ok. Rant over. I needed that.


In other news I'm headed to Shanghai this weekend with my travel buddy Ivy. No specific plans yet. I think we're going to wing it. It's a three day weekend for me. No school Monday. I might try to get another round of golf in Monday. Might be weather dependent, but at the moment the forecast is good.

57 views6 comments

Recent Posts

See All

6 Comments


Heresolong
Heresolong
Apr 28, 2023

I'd only add that maybe having more math teachers, not fewer, with input into what should be taught might actually reduce the amount that is taught. We all know that the advanced math we teach is not for everyone (God help us, we know!). It's people who don't have to teach it who have no idea how much torture we are putting those students through each and every day. Good rant, thanks Dave.

Like

Mike Durkee
Mike Durkee
Apr 27, 2023

So, I will try not to rant BUT (yes, a big but there) it has never made sense to me that we (that is 'we' as an educational system) force the vast majority of students to do the "university" track. Why do I say that? Well, roughly 60% of jobs require a 4 year degree but of that 60% I would argue that half or more of those jobs don't really 'need' to have a college degree. Of all the things I learned in high school there was only one skill that I did not have prior to high school and that is how to keyboard efficiently. I knew how to read, I knew how to do arithmetic, I knew…


Like

sunxuesong235
sunxuesong235
Apr 27, 2023

I am happy be your travel Buddy😀

Like

Narwhal. You should have gone with Narwhal.


I use math now as a 7th grade math parent. Maybe we learn math to help our kids one day with the same math. An endless, hellish loop.

Like
David Shick!
David Shick!
Apr 27, 2023
Replying to

Bye Buddy, hope you find your dad.

Like

JP Singh
JP Singh
Apr 26, 2023

>I work hard to make sure students don't feel judged by me for their struggles in math class

You were an awesome math teacher Mr shick and even when i struggled you didnt judge me, and I thank you for that experience as that helped me realize that to be a good person, one needs to despell one's own presumptions about others and you were a big part to lead me to that fact. Thank you for that


>students don't need the majority of the math we ram down their throats

I agree with this as well. i may now be taking Calculus at whatcom rn but i can already see that it wouldnt exactly help someone whos going into…


Like
Post: Blog2_Post
bottom of page