top of page
Search

Unrest in China?

Protests in the streets isn't something you hear about much in China. If you're old enough to remember a young man staring down a tank in Tiananmen Square like me you know it's a rare occurrence, and it has ended poorly for the protesters.


What do I know? Not much other than what I'm reading on American news websites.



My friend Daisy is upset, and justifiably so. Ten people were reportedly killed in a fire. The fire was in a building that was locked down. People couldn't get out. Firefighters couldn't get in. She shared this picture with me tonight.



They were two of the fire victims. That's brutal. Chinese media coverage is nonexistent because it's controlled by the party. Further, she tells me that nobody knows the results of what happened or is happening with the protesters, many on college campuses. The government can shut down internet and cell connections in any area quickly. I'll be checking out NPR a bit more in the coming days. People are getting pissed off about the lockdowns and zero tolerance Covid policies.


I was thrilled about coming to China. It has thiusands of years of history compared to our hundreds in the states. But not just the history. How do the majority of people here live day to day? How does it compare to my middle class life in the states? Do they interact in the society the same as us? If not, what's different? I went to a driving range to hit golf balls today. In the bay next to me was a tiny little girl. Maybe five or six years old. We shared a bunch of smiles. It was a cool interaction. Her mom right behind her appreciated it too. Smiles are an international language. It was the sort of thing that gives you hope. They're just like us.


I wasn't thrilled about the government here, but I knew that I would be somewhat sheltered from it working at an international school. So far, that's largely been true. However, I've made some Chinese friends here and I can see that they're hurting. That's not pleasant to see. When the person affected is a family member of a friend you feel it in a different way. The government control here is real, and people here have a legitimate fear of what could happen to them. Many living here have family that lived through horrific experiences. Famine isn't something I don't think any of my friends back in the states have first hand experience with. Having family members locked up because they were college educated is a reality that here that people know. They fear it could happen again. Given that reality it's understandable they tend not to be too outspoken. I won't judge them harshly for not taking to the streets. Dissent here is not tolerated.


Seeing it first hand here is making me appreciate what we have in the states. It's been a bit ugly the past few election cycles and we have real problems, but I don't think squashing dissent is the answer. Yes, we have health care issues. We have homelessness issues. We have poverty issues. So far it's a slam dunk choice. Casting a ballot and being allowed to bitch about society is a right I don't want to give up.

46 views5 comments

Recent Posts

See All

5 Comments


Mike Durkee
Mike Durkee
Dec 01, 2022

After seeing a news story on NBC I said to Kath, "Wonder what Dave's perspective is?" To say thank you for your side of the story is understated and greatly appreciated. Seems that the party hanger ons (there) go the same way that folks go here... generally voting their pocket book-generally! There are exceptions to that in the states (reproductive choice, sexual orientation, and guns) but to my eyes and experience it seems a bit out of the ordinary. As messy as our system is at times I very much prefer it... As you, and most of my colleagues at MHS will agree, I have a fairly difficult time holding my tongue when I perceive something as unjust or just…

Like

Thanks for the insights, interesting

Like
David Shick!
David Shick!
Nov 30, 2022
Replying to

Daisy corrected me on one of my comments. She says it't not true that people think it's not polite to discuss public issues. They do, but I'm sure I'm not aware of it as I don't understand the language. Also, she says most of the wealth here comes from relationships and connections with the party members. It's specifically this group that's afraid to say anything that the party will disapprove of.

Like

Fascinating post. Thanks for sharing. Brings up something I've been wondering about. In the states you can pretty quickly get a feel for how liberal or conservative people are. A few key social issues and we know. How does that play out there? Seems like maybe those issues are discussed much, at least not publicly? Do they even really use that terminology? From your posts it seems like the main issue is fear of what the government might do, not necessarily anything ideological. Thoughts?

Like
David Shick!
David Shick!
Nov 28, 2022
Replying to

The Chinese are a very conservative people from my perspective, but that's partially because I lean left of center. Yes, they do fear retaliation from their government, but even with that factored out they would still lean far right. Of course I have a biased view as I'm seeing this largely in regards to how they treat the youth and deal with education.


I would believe that you're going to see more liberal view points with the youth all around the world. That's no different here, but the youth here are shielded from more liberal ideology. They can't drive until they are 18. Boys can't marry until they are 22. Girls can't marry until they are 20. Shortly after arriving…

Like
Post: Blog2_Post
bottom of page